When it comes to enhancing your lashes, choosing the right mascara is essential, especially in a market flooded with options like Maybelline products. In this comparison, we will delve into the world of Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara and Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara. Both of these formulas promise volumizing effects, but their diverse features cater to different beauty needs and preferences. Whether you're seeking that perfect everyday look with the Great Lash formula or need the resilience of waterproof mascara for long wear, this analysis will highlight all the important aspects to help you decide.
Throughout our review, we will focus on several key points such as texture and consistency, the application experience, the lash effect, and how long each mascara lasts. Additionally, we’ll examine their waterproof formulations, ingredient compositions, color payoff, suitability for sensitive eyes, environmental considerations, and removing the mascara. By peeling back the layers on all these topics, you’ll be well-equipped to choose between these two popular Maybelline mascaras that best fit your needs.
- Produces rich, dramatic volume that's perfect for everyday or special occasions
- Conditioning formula helps keep lashes healthy and soft
- Easily removable with warm water or makeup remover
- Affordable and widely available at most retail locations
- Iconic product with a long-standing reputation in the cosmetics community
- May smudge or wear off during hot or humid conditions
- Requires multiple coats for maximum volume
- Blackest Black shade may not suit all skin tones and preferences
- Brush design may not be ideal for precise application
- Waterproof formula provides lasting wear, even in harsh conditions
- Great for creating bold, dramatic looks with significant volume
- Glam Black shade enhances lash definition and overall eye appearance
- Easy to apply with a thick, bristle brush that separates and lifts lashes
- Resistant to smudging and flaking for a confident look all day
- May be difficult to remove without a proper makeup remover
- Can make lashes feel stiff or brittle due to the waterproof formula
- Potential for clumping if applied in excess
- Higher price point compared to other drugstore mascaras
Texture and Consistency: A Closer Look at Maybelline Mascaras
The Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara offers a unique texture that feels lightweight upon application. Its formulation is designed to condition while it thickens, creating a soft and flexible finish on the lashes. This means that during application, the product glides smoothly without clumping, allowing for a buildable effect that enhances both volume and length. The consistency remains fluid and does not dry too quickly, which is beneficial for those who prefer to layer their mascara for a more dramatic look. Upon drying, the mascara leaves a naturally defined look, which is particularly flattering and non-stiff.
- Lightweight application
- Buildable coverage
- Soft, flexible finish
In contrast, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara is characterized by its thicker, more substantial consistency. This particular formula provides a rich, voluminous effect that is achieved quickly with fewer coats. The application can feel slightly heavier due to the added volume it delivers, but it dries to a robust finish that holds up well throughout the day. The waterproof feature of this mascara contributes to a firmer feel on the lashes, and while it may appear less flexible than the Great Lash, this firmness ensures that the lashes stay curled and volumized longer. The dramatic effect it provides is fitting for those seeking a bold and intense look.
- Thicker consistency
- Quick volumizing effect
- Firmer finish for lasting hold
Application Experience: How Each Mascara Performs
Applying Maybelline Great Lash mascara brings forth an experience characterized by its classic brush design, which is slender and tapered. This design allows for a precise application, enabling users to coat each lash from root to tip effectively. The formula, known for its volumizing properties, glides smoothly onto the lashes, providing a buildable coverage that enhances thickness without clumping. The design of the mascara brush adds to the ease of maneuvering through the lashes, making it especially user-friendly for those who may be new to mascara application. The straightforward consistency of the product also plays a crucial role in how seamlessly it applies, ensuring a comfortable experience that doesn't weigh down the lashes.
- Classic brush design allows for precise application.
- Buildable formula provides thickness without clumping.
- User-friendly for those with less experience in applying mascara.
Maybelline Volum' Express application showcases a different approach with its larger, more robust brush. This mascara brush design comparison highlights a significant difference in how the formulation interacts with the lashes. The thicker bristles are adept at capturing more product, which amplifies the volume and drama of the lashes with each stroke. The formula is created to offer a waterproof experience, allowing for extended wear throughout the day without smudging or flaking. The application process feels smooth, as the mascara dispenses evenly across the lashes, resulting in a bolder effect. Adjusting the pressure during application can yield different looks, from subtle lift to intense volume, making it versatile for various preferences.
- Larger brush captures more product for added volume.
- Waterproof formulation provides long-lasting wear.
- Smooth application allows for varying degrees of intensity.
The Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara is a classic favorite among beauty enthusiasts. Known for its iconic green and pink packaging, this mascara features a unique lash-doubling formula that works to volumize and condition your lashes simultaneously. With its application in the bold 'Blackest Black' shade, it provides a dramatic, eye-catching look that makes your eyes pop. The gentle, washable formula ensures that your lashes stay healthy and nourished throughout the day, making it perfect for everyday wear while offering easy removal at night.
Why we picked this product for our comparison
We chose the Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara for our blog because of its longstanding reputation as a staple in the beauty community. Its balance of conditioning and volumizing properties makes it ideal for users looking to enhance their lashes without compromising their health. Additionally, the ease of use and effortless removal make it suitable for both beginners and seasoned makeup lovers.
- Buy if you want a mascara that provides natural volume without clumping.
- Buy if you’re looking for a product that conditions your lashes while enhancing their length.
- Buy if you prefer a washable mascara that’s easy to remove at the end of the day.
- Buy if you seek a classic favorite that many beauty enthusiasts recommend for everyday use.
- Don't buy if you need a waterproof formula that withstands sweat and humidity.
- Don't buy if you desire a dramatic look with intense volume and fullness.
- Don't buy if you have allergies to certain mascara formulations and need to check ingredients thoroughly.
- Don't buy if you prefer a more modern applicator that provides precise application.
Lash Effect: Comparing Volume and Length
The Maybelline Great Lash lash effect features a unique volumizing lash-doubling formula designed to enhance the thickness and fullness of lashes while conditioning them. This mascara delivers impressive volume, creating a noticeable impact by coating each lash individually, which contributes to a plumper appearance. The application results in dark, rich lashes that stand out against the eyes, while the formula also works to nourish the lashes throughout the day. The blackest black shade amplifies the dark intensity, effectively transforming the overall look without clumping. Plus, its washable nature allows for easy removal at the end of the day.
- Enhances thickness and fullness of lashes.
- Conditions lashes while adding volume.
- Dark, rich black color enhances eye appearance.
On the other hand, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara emphasizes impressive volumizing capabilities, specifically crafted to deliver colossal volume results. This mascara boasts a formula that adds significant body to eyelashes, producing a bold and dramatic lash line. The waterproof feature ensures durability, making it resistant to smudging and running even in challenging conditions. While primarily focused on enhancing volume, it does provide some lengthening effects as well, giving the lashes a fuller and longer appearance. The Glam Black shade adds an alluring finish, complementing the intense volume created.
- Delivers dramatic and bold lash volume.
- Waterproof formula resists smudging and running.
- Lengthening effects complement the volume achieved.
Wear Time: Longevity of Maybelline Mascaras
When evaluating the wear time of Maybelline mascaras, the Maybelline Great Lash and the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal offer distinctly different experiences. Maybelline Great Lash is renowned for its lightweight, airy formula, which aims to volumize while still remaining easy to remove. During a standard wear test throughout the day, users noted that this mascara tends to maintain its form for several hours, yet might show signs of flaking post-lunch. The blackest black variant delivers a natural lash enhancement initially but may require midday checks to ensure it hasn’t lost some of its original definition. Special attention was given to its potential for smudging; under regular daily activities, very minimal smudging was observed, leading to an impression that it holds its ground adequately without heavy rainfall or excessive moisture.
- Flaking tendencies increase after about 5-6 hours of wear.
- Smudging remains minimal, showing good resilience under normal conditions.
- Retention of the volume effect diminishes slightly by mid-afternoon.
In contrast, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara is designed to withstand harsher conditions, making it a candidate for those seeking superior durability. With its waterproof feature, this mascara performs exceptionally well against moisture, ensuring that the lashes stay lifted and voluminous throughout the day. Observations indicated that after a full day's wear, this product exhibited little to no flaking, indicating a higher level of Maybelline mascara wear time. Additionally, smudging was virtually non-existent, even in humid environments or during physical activities. The color intensity remained impressive until the end of the day, allowing wearers to enjoy bold lashes without frequent touch-ups.
- Flaking resistance is superior, lasting well beyond 10 hours.
- No noticeable smudging even under sweat-inducing conditions.
- The color and volume of lashes remain consistent throughout the wear period.
Waterproof Formulations: Testing Performance Under Water
The Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara is designed with waterproof capabilities that far exceed those of traditional formulas. When subjected to water or high humidity, Colossal's waterproof mascara effectiveness is often highlighted by its ability to resist smudging and running. This formulation incorporates a unique blend of ingredients that help it adhere to the lashes, creating a thick, voluminous look without the fear of it washing away. Many users appreciate how well it holds up against rain or tears, allowing for a confident application throughout the day. Additionally, the waterproof formula aids in maintaining the integrity of the lash lift, ensuring that the mascara remains intact even when faced with moisture.
- Delivers dramatic volume without clumping.
- Designed to withstand sweat and humidity.
- Retains a long-lasting finish throughout wear.
In contrast, the Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara has a different approach to water exposure. Known for its lightweight formula, it offers a more easily removable option for those who prefer a simpler cleanup at the end of the day. The Great Lash’s water resistance is effective for daily wear; however, it is not designed to withstand heavy moisture as effectively as its waterproof counterpart. During rigorous activities or exposure to high humidity, users often find that the Great Lash may smudge or run. This kind of performance can be ideal for those seeking a natural look without the commitment of a waterproof formula, but it does not provide the level of durability seen in the Colossal mascara waterproof test.
- Ideal for a more casual, everyday makeup look.
- Easily washed off with soap and water.
- Offers moderate volumizing effect without heaviness.
For those seeking an even more dramatic lash effect, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara stands out as a top choice. This mascara is formulated to give you colossal volume without clumping, allowing for fuller and thicker lashes. With its Glam Black shade, it enhances the natural beauty of your eyes, providing depth and allure. The waterproof formula ensures that your look stays intact through humidity, sweat, and tears, making it a reliable option for special occasions or long days out. This mascara is all about bold volume while maintaining lash health.
Why we picked this product for our comparison
The Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara was selected for its ability to deliver impressive volume with a reliable waterproof formula. It caters to those who desire a bold look that lasts throughout the day, regardless of environmental challenges. Its standout features make it a fantastic option for anyone wanting to achieve drama in their lashes without worry, aligning with our goal of highlighting products that work hard for you.
- Buy if you want a mascara that delivers bold volume and an eye-catching look.
- Buy if you need a waterproof formula that will last through long days and humid conditions.
- Buy if you appreciate an easy-to-apply mascara that glides on smoothly without clumping.
- Buy if you're a fan of deep, rich colors that enhance the allure of your eyes.
- Don't buy if you prefer a mascara that is easy to remove at the end of the day.
- Don't buy if you are sensitive to the heaviness of waterproof formulas on your lashes.
- Don't buy if you want a natural look rather than dramatic volume.
- Don't buy if you want a mascara that offers conditioning benefits to your lashes.
Ingredient Composition: A Breakdown of Formulas
The first product, Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara, features a unique blend of ingredients aimed at both volumizing and conditioning the lashes. The key components include nourishing conditioning agents that contribute to lash health while providing a thicker appearance. Ingredients like beeswax and carnauba wax play a crucial role in forming a flexible film on the lashes, which aids in curl and separation. Additionally, Maybelline mascara ingredients list various polymers that help in achieving the desired volumizing effect, ensuring that each lash is coated evenly without clumping. The formula’s lightweight nature makes it easy to apply and remove, which is appealing for daily wear.
- Contains nourishing conditioning agents to promote lash health.
- Utilizes beeswax and carnauba wax for flexible lash styling.
- Includes volumizing polymers for even coating and volume.
In contrast, Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara is formulated with a thicker consistency that caters specifically to users seeking long-lasting wear and enhanced volume. This mascara incorporates a greater ratio of waxes and film-forming agents, which facilitate a more dramatic effect. Key ingredients such as hydrolyzed silk and collagen derivatives are included to strengthen lashes while adding volume. The waterproof feature of this mascara stems from specialized water-resistant polymers that ensure longevity against moisture. The emphasis on volumizing polymers sets this formula apart, making it ideal for those looking for a bold, smudge-proof finish.
- Features a thicker consistency for enhanced volumizing effects.
- Contains hydrolyzed silk and collagen derivatives for lash strength.
- Includes specialized polymers for waterproof wear and longevity.
You May Also Like
wet n wild High On Lash Eyelash Curler with Comfort Grip
$3.83 $3.19
Neutrogena Makeup Remover Wipes, Ultra-Soft Cleansing Facial Towelettes for Waterproof Makeup, Alcohol-Free, Plant-Based, Twin Pack, 25 Count (Pack of 2)
$16.43 $13.69
Highly Pigmented Eye Makeup Palette, Matte Shimmer Metallic Eyeshadow Pallet Long Lasting Blendable Natural Colors Make Up Eye Shadows Cosmetics Gift Kit
$11.99 $9.99
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Black 0.006 Oz
$6.00 $5.00Color Payoff: Analyzing Shade Depth and Intensity
The Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara showcases a vivid shade depth noted for its rich pigmentation in the "Blackest Black" variant. Upon application, users often observe that this mascara delivers a classic, jet-black finish that effectively enhances lash visibility, creating a bold look that stands out. The consistency of the formula allows for easy layering, ensuring that the intensity can be adjusted according to preference. This mascara not only thickens the lashes but also conditions them, supporting the color retention over time, allowing for a consistently striking appearance throughout the day.
- Rich pigmentation contributing to a classic look
- Easy layering for customizable intensity
On the other hand, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara presents a different approach with its "Glam Black" shade. This formulation is designed to emphasize volume while still offering a striking dark finish, albeit with a slightly different interpretation of black. The waterproof formula enhances longevity, ensuring that the intensity remains bold despite moisture or humidity. Users often remark on how this mascara seals in the color, creating a dynamic contrast against the whites of the eyes and producing a stunning effect ideal for various occasions.
- Emphasizes volumization with a vibrant dark finish
- Waterproof formula ensures lasting intensity
Suitability for Sensitive Eyes: Formulations Examined
Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara is often lauded for its suitability for sensitive eyes, thanks in part to its hypoallergenic properties. The formulation is designed to minimize irritation, making it a favorable option for individuals who may experience discomfort from traditional mascaras. One of the standout features of this mascara is its conditioning formula, which thickens while adding volume without introducing harsh chemicals that can lead to allergic reactions. Additionally, the eye safety certifications associated with the Great Lash line enhance its appeal, further assuring users of its gentleness on delicate eye areas.
- Hypoallergenic formulation reduces the risk of irritation.
- Conditioning components promote lash health.
- Meets rigorous eye safety testing standards.
In contrast, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara presents a different set of characteristics for those with sensitive eyes. While waterproof formulas generally offer longevity and resistance to smudging, they can often include more robust components that may be irritating for some users. This mascara, with its volumizing properties, can create dramatic looks, but the water-resistant agents might not be the best option for everyone. Users with particularly sensitive eyes should assess the formulation for potential allergens, especially as waterproof mascaras often require more intense removal methods that could lead to increased eye irritation.
- Waterproof formula provides extended wear.
- Possible allergens may require careful evaluation.
- Removal process can be more irritating for sensitive eyes.
Related Products
Environmental Considerations: Eco-Friendly Aspects
Maybelline’s Great Lash Washable Mascara embodies an approach toward sustainability through its eco-friendly mascara packaging. The brand has implemented measures that allow consumers to recycle their mascara tubes once they are emptied. The Great Lash line is noted for its use of less complex materials in its product design, allowing for more straightforward recycling processes. Additionally, the ingredients in this mascara focus on conditioning agents that are designed to minimize environmental impact while still delivering performance. The brand promotes a commitment to transparency in its ingredient sourcing, reliably aiming for sustainable Maybelline products that are kinder to both the user and the Earth.
- Recyclable mascara packaging, promoting waste reduction.
- Focus on conditioning ingredients that reduce ecological harm.
- Transparency in ingredient sourcing for eco-conscious consumers.
On the other hand, Maybelline's Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara presents its own unique considerations regarding sustainability. The packaging of this product, while being effective in preserving the mascara’s integrity, may not be as easily recyclable due to its more complex material composition designed for waterproof capabilities. However, Maybelline is actively addressing the mascara environmental impact through initiatives aimed at improving packaging recyclability overall. Ingredients in this formula are carefully selected for both effectiveness and sustainability, reflecting an ongoing commitment to creating sustainable Maybelline products that strive to lessen their ecological footprint.
- Complex packaging that may hinder recycling efforts.
- Focus on improving recyclability through corporate sustainability initiatives.
- Ingredient choices that prioritize both performance and eco-friendliness.
Removing the Mascara: Ease and Effectiveness
When it comes to removing Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara, the process is relatively straightforward due to its washable formula. To efficiently remove this mascara, warm water and a gentle cleanser are typically recommended. Users should start by wetting their lashes with warm water, which helps to loosen the mascara. Next, applying a gentle makeup remover or cleansing oil onto a cotton pad, and sweeping it across the lashes in an upward motion can effectively lift the product off without tugging at the delicate skin around the eyes. The addition of a follow-up rinse with warm water helps ensure that all remnants are removed, contributing to clean and hydrated lashes. For added ease, utilizing a designated eye makeup remover is highly effective. This type of product is specifically designed to break down mascara quickly, thereby simplifying the removal process further.
- Warm water aids in loosening the mascara.
- Gentle cleansers prevent irritation.
- Cleansing oils enhance removal effectiveness.
On the other hand, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara presents a distinct challenge when it comes to removal. As a waterproof formula, it typically requires a more robust approach to ensure all traces are eliminated. The best way to remove waterproof mascara involves using an oil-based makeup remover or waterproof makeup remover wipes. Saturate a cotton pad with the remover and press it gently against the lashes for several seconds to allow the product to dissolve the mascara. Then, gently swipe the pad downward, making sure to carefully remove the mascara without harsh rubbing. Following up with a mild cleanser will help address any remaining residue. This method not only ensures the lashes are clean but protects them from breakage or damage often associated with vigorous rubbing.
- Oil-based removers are essential for effectiveness.
- Gentle pressing helps dissolve the waterproof formula.
- Mild cleansers minimize potential irritation after removal.
Our Final Recommendation
After evaluating these two well-loved mascaras, it’s clear that both the Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara and the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara have their unique strengths suited for different types of lash goals. While the Great Lash offers a classic texture and is easy to remove, making it ideal for everyday use, the Colossal Waterproof variant excels in durability and moisture resistance for those who need their makeup to last through any scenario. This dedication to performance is particularly beneficial for active individuals or those living in humid climates.
Ultimately, if you are looking for a mascara that combines volumizing impact with the power to withstand water and longevity, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara takes the win in this comparison. Its ability to hold up throughout the day and provide a striking, glam black finish makes it the superior choice for anyone in search of long-lasting performance without compromising on volume.
