When it comes to enhancing our lashes, choosing the right mascara is essential for achieving the desired look. The Maybelline Great Lash series has long been a favorite among beauty enthusiasts, known for its innovative formulas and impressive results. Today, we're diving deep into a side-by-side comparison of two popular offerings: Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara and Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara. Both products boast unique qualities that cater to different lash needs, making this an exciting exploration for anyone looking to elevate their mascara game.
As we delve into the details of these two beloved mascaras, we will explore various factors such as the volumizing capabilities, lengthening effects, and how each product enhances the natural lash appearance. Whether you're a fan of the original formula or curious about the benefits of the BIG version, this comparison will provide you with valuable insights. With so much to uncover, let's get started on this beauty journey to help you find your perfect match!
- Offers a classic volumizing effect that enhances lash thickness.
- Conditioning formula that cares for lashes while providing volume.
- Blackest Black shade delivers a bold, intense look.
- Washable formula is easy to remove, perfect for everyday use.
- May not provide as much lengthening effect compared to other mascaras.
- Can clump if applied in multiple layers.
- Brush may not suit everyone's application style.
- Volumizing, thickening, and lengthening formula creates a dramatic look.
- Brownish Black shade offers a softer, more natural appearance.
- Great for layering without becoming too heavy or clumpy.
- Well-designed brush promotes even application across all lashes.
- May require multiple coats for the desired volume and length.
- Washable formula may not hold up against tears or humidity.
- The brownish black color may not be suitable for those wanting a more dramatic lash effect.
Comparing Volume: Maybelline Great Lash vs. Great Lash BIG
The Maybelline Great Lash mascara boasts a longstanding reputation as one of the best volumizing mascaras on the market. Its volumizing lash-doubling formula is designed to condition lashes while providing thickness and fullness. The key ingredient that supports its volumizing capabilities is a base that promises to enhance the volume of each lash without clumping, ensuring a natural look that many users appreciate. The applicator features a classic slim brush that effectively coats each lash from root to tip, allowing for precise application and subtle volume enhancement. The formula is available in shades like Blackest Black, appealing to those who desire a striking finish. This combination of a well-crafted formulation and a manageable brush design contributes to achieving the dramatic volume that has led to numerous positive Maybelline Great Lash reviews.
- Volumizing lash-doubling formula.
- Classic slim brush for precision.
- Conditioning properties for healthier-looking lashes.
- Available in striking shades like Blackest Black.
In contrast, the Maybelline Great Lash BIG takes the concept of volumization to a new level with its larger brush design and thicker formula. The Great Lash BIG vs regular version utilizes a noticeably bigger brush that captures more lashes, enabling an ultra-volumizing effect that can transform even the sparsest of lashes into a fuller appearance. The thicker consistency of this mascara helps to add substantial volume and drama, creating a bold look suitable for those who prefer an emphasis on fullness and definition. The thickening and lengthening properties combined with the impressive brush make this variation ideal for achieving a glamorous, eye-catching effect. Available in shades like Brownish Black, it caters to users who seek a sophisticated yet striking appeal.
- Large brush design for enhanced coverage.
- Thicker formula for maximum volume.
- Bold finish with noticeable fullness.
- Ideal for those looking for dramatic looks.
Lengthening Effects of Maybelline Great Lash and Great Lash BIG
When analyzing the lengthening effects of Maybelline Great Lash and Great Lash BIG, the differences in formulation and brush design play a crucial role. Great Lash mascara features a classic formula known for its ability to enhance the natural length of lashes while providing a touch of volume. The lightweight consistency allows for buildable application, which enables users to achieve a more elongated look with multiple coats. This mascara is enriched with conditioning ingredients that help maintain lash health while offering a smooth finish. The traditional brush, designed for separation, works to coat each lash evenly, ensuring that even the tiniest lashes are visible. In contrast, Great Lash BIG uses a more advanced, thicker formula aimed at delivering both volume and length. The oversized brush is specifically crafted to grab each lash and extend it, giving the appearance of dramatic length. This product utilizes a unique blend of polymers that adhere to lashes, promoting a lifted effect without clumping.
- Great Lash mascara features a lightweight formula ideal for a natural elongation.
- Great Lash BIG's thicker formula and oversized brush offer enhanced length and volume.
The ingredients in both mascaras contribute to their respective lengthening abilities. Great Lash mascara includes conditioning agents and a gentle formula that supports lash health, which can indirectly contribute to the perception of length over time. The buildable nature of this mascara allows it to increase the overall appearance of lash length with repeated applications. Great Lash BIG, however, contains polymers that enable a more noticeable lengthening effect immediately upon application. This combination of a rich formula and a large brush makes it easier for users to achieve long lashes without several layers of product. Both products invite unique application practices; Great Lash requires finesse and multiple coats to achieve optimal length, while Great Lash BIG allows for a more straightforward application that maximizes results in fewer strokes.
- Great Lash mascara features conditioning ingredients that support lash health.
- Great Lash BIG’s formula promotes immediate lengthening results with a more effortless application process.
Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara is a beauty staple known for its remarkable performance. This volumizing lash-doubling formula conditions your lashes while adding a significant thickness that enhances their natural beauty. The Blackest Black shade ensures a bold and dramatic look, perfect for both everyday wear and special occasions. Its user-friendly design allows for easy application, making it a favorite among makeup enthusiasts and professionals alike. With 1 count in each package, you have the power to achieve stunning, eye-catching lashes with every swipe.
Why we picked this product for our comparison
We chose Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara because it remains a classic in the beauty world, revered for its ability to deliver consistent results. Its combination of volumizing properties and conditioning formula makes it an exceptional choice for those seeking enhanced yet healthy lashes. The Blackest Black color option allows users to achieve a bold look effortlessly, making it a must-have in any makeup arsenal.
Additionally, the ease of application and removal sets it apart from many competitors. It’s perfect for both beginners and seasoned makeup aficionados, which is why we feel it deserves a top spot in our recommendations.
- Buy if you want a classic mascara that delivers excellent volume without clumping.
- Buy if you're looking for a product that conditions your lashes while enhancing them.
- Buy if you prefer a classic black finish to make your lashes stand out.
- Buy if you appreciate the ease of washable formulas that can be removed easily.
- Buy if you're on a budget but still want quality mascara that performs well.
- Don't buy if you need a waterproof formula for long-lasting wear in humid conditions.
- Don't buy if you're seeking a mascara that provides intense length in addition to volume.
- Don't buy if you prefer a more dramatic, bold look than this natural finish offers.
- Don't buy if you have sensitive eyes and require hypoallergenic products.
- Don't buy if you're looking for an innovative brush design for precision application.
Brush Design: A Look at Maybelline Great Lash Brushes
Examining the brush designs of Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara and Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara reveals distinct characteristics that influence their application and performance. The Great Lash brush design for the original version features a traditional, slender brush with soft bristles that taper at the end. This design allows for precise application, making it easier to reach the inner and outer corners of the eyes. The bristles are spaced moderately apart, which helps separate the lashes while delivering a natural-looking volumizing effect. It effectively coats each lash from root to tip without clumping, making it suitable for those who prefer a light, everyday look. Additionally, the flexibility of the soft bristles enhances the user experience, providing gentle application that does not tug at delicate lashes. The
- Traditional slender shape enhances precision
- Soft bristles for gentle application
- Moderate spacing for lash separation and volume
In contrast, the Great Lash BIG brush design incorporates a larger, fluffy brush that amplifies volume significantly. This design features a wider brush head and denser bristle arrangement, allowing for a bolder application that is perfect for those who seek dramatic effects. The innovative brush design captures more product and distributes it evenly across the lashes, which not only thickens but also lengthens them. The larger design can offer a more rapid application process since more surface area is covered with each swipe. However, this may make it a bit less precise for smaller eyes compared to the original version. Users often appreciate the extravagance of the
- Larger fluffy brush that maximizes volume
- Dense bristles for quick application
- Captures more mascara for thicker, longer lashes
Color Options in Maybelline Great Lash Series
The Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara offers an iconic choice with its "Blackest Black" shade. This rich hue is designed to accentuate dark lashes, creating a striking contrast against lighter eye colors. The intensity of "Blackest Black" is complemented by its volumizing lash-doubling formula, which not only enhances the color but also conditions lashes while adding thickness. This is particularly appealing for users who desire bold, dramatic eyes and need mascara shades for dark lashes that deliver an impactful look.
- Intense color payoff for a dramatic effect
- Conditioning formula that nourishes lashes
- Perfect for achieving a classic glamour look
In contrast, the Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara in "Brownish Black" provides a more understated option for those who prefer a softer, more natural appearance. This shade strikes a fine balance, offering subtle depth without overwhelming the eye. The volumizing and thickening properties of this mascara work beautifully to enhance the eyes while remaining elegant. For individuals who enjoy a more everyday, wearable look, the "Brownish Black" is a fantastic choice, making it suitable for various occasions. This mascara also exemplifies how different color options can significantly alter the overall look and feel of the makeup.
- Soft yet effective for a more natural look
- Enhances lashes without overpowering the eye
- Ideal for daily wear and versatile styles
Formulation Differences: What Sets Them Apart?
The two Maybelline products, Great Lash Washable Mascara and Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara, exhibit distinct formulation differences that significantly impact their overall performance. The Great Lash Washable Mascara, known for its volumizing lash-doubling formula, contains unique ingredients designed for optimal conditioning and thickening benefits. For instance, this formulation emphasizes a lightweight feel while still enhancing the appearance of lash volume. The blackest black shade provides a striking contrast to the pigmentation of lashes, and it’s designed to create a subtle but effective lift without weighing them down. The conditioning properties directly contribute to wear-time by preventing brittle lashes, allowing for comfortable all-day use.
- A focus on lash health with conditioning agents.
- Weighted texture for a natural-looking enhancement.
- Suitable for those seeking an everyday look without clumps.
In contrast, the Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara delivers amplified performance due to its thicker, more intense formula which not only volumizes but also lengthens lashes dramatically. This formulation incorporates additional polymers that adhere more firmly to the lashes, ensuring they maintain their bold look throughout the day. The brownish black shade offers a softer alternative to the standard black, catering to those who prefer less intensity in their eye makeup. The emphasis on thickness in the Great Lash BIG formulation provides a more dramatic effect but may not prioritize lash conditioning as inherently as the original Great Lash. This can affect comfort for individuals who wear mascara for extended periods.
- Enhanced volumizing and lengthening with added polymers.
- Creates a more dramatic appearance for special occasions.
- The texture may feel slightly heavier due to increased product density.
Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara takes lash enhancement to the next level. Designed to volumize, thicken, and lengthen, this mascara in Brownish Black delivers a striking appearance while providing all-day wear. The unique brush and formula work together to coat and extend even the tiniest lashes, offering a lush, full look. Easy to wash off, it does not compromise on performance. With 1 count per package, this is the go-to choice for those wanting a dramatic eye effect without the hassle of complicated application.
Why we picked this product for our comparison
We selected Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara for its ability to transform lashes dramatically. Its unique formula not only thickens and volumizes but also lengthens, offering a complete enhancement that few products can promise. The Brownish Black shade is an excellent alternative for those who prefer a softer, more natural look without sacrificing intensity.
The versatility of this mascara, paired with its easy application process, caters to various makeup styles, making it an impressive addition to any collection. This product stands out for delivering outstanding results while being simple to use, which is why we highly recommend it.
- Buy if you want a mascara that maximizes volume while also lengthening your lashes.
- Buy if you're looking for a rich brownish-black shade for a softer, more natural look.
- Buy if you appreciate a thickening formula that delivers noticeable results.
- Buy if you need a versatile product that works for both day and night looks.
- Buy if you want a reliable and user-friendly mascara that enhances your lashes effortlessly.
- Don't buy if you need a waterproof option for all-day wear in difficult weather.
- Don't buy if you have extremely fine lashes and need very light formulas that won't weigh them down.
- Don't buy if you're searching for a product that delivers a dramatic false lash effect.
- Don't buy if you have a preference for high-end mascaras with unique applicators.
- Don't buy if you experience irritation with certain formulas and require sensitivity-tested products.
Application Techniques for Great Lash vs. Great Lash BIG
When it comes to Great Lash application techniques, achieving the ideal look involves a straightforward yet effective approach. The original Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara is known for its conditioning formula, which naturally thickens lashes while providing a delicate volume boost. To apply this mascara, begin at the base of the lashes, wiggling the brush back and forth to help separate and coat each lash evenly. The classic formula allows for layering; applying an additional coat while the first coat is still slightly wet can enhance the volumizing effect without clumping. For those seeking a more defined lash look, utilize the tip of the brush to pinch and lift the lashes at the corners for a subtle, fanned-out appearance.
- Start at the base of the lashes and wiggle the brush upwards.
- Layer while the first coat is wet for better volumization.
- Use the brush tip for precise corner lifting.
In contrast, mascara application methods for Maybelline Great Lash BIG invite a bolder and more dramatic effect. This thicker, more volumizing formula is designed to enhance both the length and the volume of your lashes, requiring a slightly different technique for optimal results. Begin in the same fashion by applying at the base and wiggling the brush, but with the Great Lash BIG, a slow and steady upward stroke helps prevent clumping due to its thicker texture. For a more intense look, it’s beneficial to allow each coat to dry for a few seconds before adding subsequent layers. This caution helps maintain a fuller appearance while reducing the risk of heaviness in the final look, which can be particularly advantageous for those aiming for a standout, bold lash effect.
- Apply with slow, steady strokes to prevent clumping.
- Allow each coat to dry slightly before applying more.
- Focus on building volume gradually for a full, dramatic appearance.
You May Also Like
wet n wild High On Lash Eyelash Curler with Comfort Grip
$3.83 $3.19
Neutrogena Makeup Remover Wipes, Ultra-Soft Cleansing Facial Towelettes for Waterproof Makeup, Alcohol-Free, Plant-Based, Twin Pack, 25 Count (Pack of 2)
$16.43 $13.69
Highly Pigmented Eye Makeup Palette, Matte Shimmer Metallic Eyeshadow Pallet Long Lasting Blendable Natural Colors Make Up Eye Shadows Cosmetics Gift Kit
$11.99 $9.99
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Black 0.006 Oz
$6.00 $5.00Water Resistance: Maybelline Mascara Features
The Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara is known for its gentle yet effective formula that emphasizes volumizing your lashes without compromising their health. In humid conditions, this mascara performs admirably but isn't labeled as waterproof, making it susceptible to smudging if exposed to significant moisture, such as rain or sweat. Users often appreciate its ability to provide lush, thick lashes thanks to its unique lash-doubling formula that conditions as it thickens, but some may find that the lack of robust water resistance limits its wear during more active situations. The product's washability is its main feature, offering an easy cleanse at the end of the day without the need for heavy removers or oils. This mascara's performance can be summarized as effective for daily use but requiring careful consideration if you are in high-humidity or tear-inducing environments.
- Volumizing and conditioning benefits
- Prone to smudging in humid conditions
- Easy removal without harsh chemicals
In contrast, the Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara offers a slightly different experience, with a focus on achieving thicker and longer lashes for that dramatic look. Despite being marketed as washable, some users find that it holds up better than its counterpart under humid conditions due to its enhanced formulation that provides more volume. Nevertheless, it shares similar limitations regarding the waterproof vs washable mascara debate, still leading to the potential for smudging and running when exposed to tears or perspiration. Many avid users of this option appreciate the volume and length it provides but should remain cautious about its performance during activities that induce sweat. The mascara's gentle formula also allows for hassle-free removal, which many customers deem an advantage.
- Thicker and longer lash effect
- Better performance in humid climates compared to some standards
- Ease of removal without drying out the lashes
How Each Mascara Enhances Natural Lash Appearance
The Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara is renowned for its ability to create a classic, natural look. This mascara features a volumizing lash-doubling formula that thickens lashes while adding just the right amount of definition. Its blackest black shade provides depth without looking overly dramatic, making it ideal for daily wear. The finish tends to be slightly matte, which enhances the natural appearance of lashes, as it refrains from adding excessive sheen. The formula not only volumizes but also conditions as it thickens, leading to healthier-looking lashes over time. Wearers often appreciate how easily it separates and defines individual lashes, contributing to an effortlessly elegant effect.
- Classic matte finish for a natural look
- Volumizing formula doubles the thickness of lashes
- Conditions lashes for added health
In contrast, the Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara offers a different dimension to the enhancement of lashes. This version contains a thicker, more intense formula that is designed to volumize, thicken, and lengthen lashes more dramatically. The brownish black shade gives a softer appearance than typical black mascaras, catering to those who prefer a less intense look while still maintaining a defined lash line. The glossy finish provides a modern flair, and users often note that the application yields a fuller lash appearance without clumping. This mascara works exceptionally well for a bolder yet sophisticated natural effect, making it a great choice for both day and night looks.
- Glossy finish enhances visual appeal
- Thicker formula for volume and length
- Brownish black for a softer appearance
Related Products
User Experiences: What Do Customers Say?
When examining the Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara, user feedback reveals a strong sense of nostalgia intertwined with the product's effectiveness. Many customers express appreciation for the classic formula, highlighting how it effortlessly highlights their lashes without clumping. Reports frequently mention ease of application, with users noting that the wand design allows for precise application even in hard-to-reach areas. The Maybelline mascara user reviews indicate that this product not only adds volume but also conditions lashes as it thickens, which has resonated well with customers aiming for both aesthetics and lash health. Users often share their satisfaction with how the blackest black shade truly delivers on its promise, making eyes look more defined and vibrant. Also mentioned is the ease of removal, which adds to the overall user experience.
- Classic and effective formula appreciated by many.
- Precise application noted due to wand design.
- Conditioning properties resonate with lash health seekers.
- Blackest black provides definition and vibrancy.
- Ease of removal contributes to user satisfaction.
In contrast, the Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara showcases a slightly different profile in user experiences. Customers often highlight its voluminous and thickening capabilities, with a significant number emphasizing that it lives up to its name. The Brownish Black shade is particularly appreciated for those preferring a softer but equally impactful look. Users note that the texture feels richer, allowing for a bolder finish while maintaining a lightweight feel. Many highlight how it performs well throughout the day without flaking, which adds to its appeal as a long-lasting option. The application process is also noted to be smooth, with minimal effort required to achieve desired lash lengths. Reviews frequently refer to the mascara user experiences as transformative, especially for those seeking a more dramatic effect without the heaviness typically associated with volumizing products.
- Users emphasize its ability to provide volume and thickness.
- Brownish Black shade appreciated for a softer look.
- Texture feels rich, delivering a bold finish.
- Performs well throughout the day without flaking.
- Smooth application noted, achieving desired lash lengths easily.
Packaging and Design: Maybelline Mascara Differences
The packaging of Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara features a classic and iconic design that has remained largely unchanged over the years. Housed in a slender and easy-to-hold tube, the eye-catching bright pink color is complemented by a green cap, creating a cheerful and youthful vibe. This aesthetic appeals to a broad demographic, as the familiar look evokes nostalgia while still attracting new customers. The tube's design is practical; its narrow shape allows for simple handling during application, while the twist-off cap ensures effortless access to the mascara, providing a seamless user experience.
- Classic tube design for easy handling
- Colorful packaging enhances shelf appeal
- Simple access with a twist-off cap
In contrast, Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara boasts a more modern and robust look. The packaging design is bolder, featuring a thicker tube that gives it a more substantial feel. This product employs a dynamic black and pink color scheme, which may convey strength and sophistication compared to the original. Additionally, the wider brush that accompanies the mascara indicates its focus on volume and lengthening benefits. Aimed at consumers who prioritize these features, the design differentiates itself in a crowded market. The packaging seeks to enhance the perception of performance, suggesting a more powerful formula that aligns with contemporary beauty trends.
- Thicker tube design for a robust feel
- Dynamic color scheme conveys strength
- Wider brush emphasizes volumizing effects
Our Final Recommendation
After meticulously examining the features, formulations, and user experiences of both Maybelline Great Lash Washable Mascara and Maybelline Great Lash BIG Washable Mascara, it’s clear that each product has its strengths. While Great Lash offers a reliable and classic approach to volumizing and thickening, the Great Lash BIG elevates this experience by providing thicker application and remarkable length without clumping. If you're looking for an all-in-one mascara that delivers on volume, length, and ease of use, the Great Lash BIG is undoubtedly the winner of this comparison.
Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on personal preferences and lash goals. For those who desire more dramatic, fuller lashes with minimal effort, Great Lash BIG stands out. However, if you favor a more lightweight, traditional makeup experience, the original Great Lash remains a solid choice. Whichever mascara you opt for, you can trust that Maybelline has crafted a product that prioritizes lash health and enhancement.
