Choosing the right mascara can significantly enhance your eye makeup game, and with so many options available, it’s essential to narrow down your choices to the best contenders. In this comparison, we delve deep into two popular products from Maybelline: the Great Lash Waterproof Mascara and the Volum' Express Falsies Mascara. Both promise to deliver voluminous and captivating lashes but do they deliver what they promise? With features such as waterproofing, color richness, and unique formulas, understanding their strengths will help you determine which mascara aligns with your beauty needs.
We'll explore various aspects like volume boost, lengthening effects, and user experiences to provide a comprehensive view of how each mascara performs. Whether you're looking for a classic, time-tested formula like Great Lash or leaning towards the innovative design of the Falsies, this analysis aims to lay out the crucial differences clearly. We'll not only talk about how these mascaras fare under daily wear but also if they hold up to different environments, giving you insights into which may deserve a spot in your makeup bag.
- Waterproof formula ensures long-lasting wear, perfect for all-day use.
- Volumizing and lengthening properties create fuller, thicker lashes.
- Rich Very Black shade enhances the intensity and impact of your eye makeup.
- Easy to apply with a comfortable wand for precise application.
- Affordable price point for quality performance.
- Can be difficult to remove due to its waterproof formula.
- Some users may find it clumpy if too many layers are applied.
- Formula may dry out quicker than other mascaras.
- Washable formula allows for easy removal, making it user-friendly.
- Creates dramatic volume, making lashes appear longer and fuller.
- Blackest Black shade offers a bold and striking look.
- Unique brush design separates and coats every lash evenly.
- Lightweight feel; doesn't weigh down lashes throughout the day.
- Not waterproof, which may not hold up in humid conditions.
- May require multiple applications for full effect.
- Some users report smudging during wear.
Volume Boost: Great Lash vs. Falsies Mascara
When it comes to achieving thicker lashes, both the Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara and the Maybelline Volum' Express Falsies Mascara have garnered attention in the volumizing mascara comparison market. Users of Great Lash often highlight how the formula effortlessly builds on each coat, resulting in a lifted and full appearance. Many appreciate its lightweight consistency, which allows for natural-looking lengthening, yet some feel it lacks the dramatic volume that can be achieved with other brands. However, they commend its ability to provide an everyday look that enhances lash thickness with its classic lash-doubling formula. Reviewers enjoy the true-black finish of this mascara that complements any makeup style, celebrating it as one of the best volumizing mascara options for a subtle yet notable impact.
- Lightweight feel for comfortable wear
- Classic lash-doubling formula for everyday use
- Natural enhancement of lash thickness
On the other hand, the Falsies Mascara stands out with its unique brush design that promises to create a feathery volume. Users rave about the dramatic effect it delivers, asserting that their lashes appear significantly fuller and more defined. Many describe their experience as transformative, achieving a false-lash look without the actual application of faux lashes. The Falsies Mascara, in its Blackest Black shade, gives an intense volumizing effect that amplifies every swipe, drawing attention to one's eyes. While some may find the potential for clumping with multiple coats, others see this as an opportunity to layer for maximum impact, making it a favorite for those seeking bolder lashes.
- Unique brush design for dramatic volume
- Intense color for enhanced eye definition
- Transforms lashes for a false-lash effect
Lengthening Effects: Great Lash and Falsies Mascara
The Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara is renowned for its unique lash-doubling formula that not only volumizes but also emphasizes lash length. Users have noted that the brush design allows for great separation of lashes, making them look visibly longer without clumping. One standout feature is the voluminous effect it imparts; many users report that they see a dramatic enhancement in their lash length, especially when multiple coats are applied. The Very Black shade is specifically favored for creating a bold look, further contributing to the overall illusion of longer lashes. Additionally, the waterproof formula lends a long-lasting hold, ensuring that those elongated lashes stay put throughout the day, resisting any potential smudging or flaking.
- The brush technology promotes even distribution of product.
- Multiple coats can intensify lengthening effects.
- Water-resistant formula ensures durability.
In contrast, the Maybelline Volum' Express Falsies Mascara takes a different approach to achieving lash length. This formula is designed specifically for achieving the look of false lashes, which emphasizes both volume and length in a dramatic fashion. Many users have praised the innovative brush that shapes the lashes while lifting them. The Blackest Black color enhances the eyes and works exceptionally well in creating a striking appearance. Those seeking a mascara known for lengthening lashes often highlight its ability to reach even the smallest lashes, making them appear longer as it coats every strand. The washable formula also makes it a favorite for those who wish to remove makeup easily without the fuss of waterproof products, enabling a hassle-free end to the day.
- Innovative brush lifts and shapes lashes effectively.
- Creates a dramatic, false lash effect.
- Washable formula allows for easy removal.
The Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara is a classic beauty staple that has stood the test of time. With its volumizing, lengthening, and lash-doubling formula, this mascara helps you achieve thicker, more defined lashes that last all day. The very black color enhances the natural beauty of your eyes, making them pop with every blink. Its waterproof formula means you can enjoy your vibrant look without worrying about smudging or flaking, even on the hottest days or during emotional moments. Conveniently packaged in a 1-count tube, it's the perfect addition to your makeup bag for any occasion.
Why we picked this product for our comparison
The Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara is a beloved product among makeup enthusiasts, and for good reason. Its time-tested formula provides a balance of volume and length that not many competitors can match. Users appreciate its reliable waterproof feature, providing peace of mind for both everyday wear and special events. Additionally, the affordability of this high-quality mascara makes it accessible to a wide audience, solidifying its place as a makeup essential.
Our blog chosen it due to its excellent customer reviews and its position as a cult favorite in the beauty community. This mascara not only enhances your lashes but also does so with a trusted brand reputation, making it a go-to for beauty lovers everywhere.
- Buy if you seek a reliable waterproof formula that withstands tears and humidity.
- Buy if you want to enhance your lashes with a volumizing and lengthening effect.
- Buy if you appreciate a classic, iconic mascara that's been trusted for generations.
- Buy if you prefer a very black finish that adds drama to your eyes.
- Buy if you want a product that easy to remove with makeup remover at the end of the day.
- Don't buy if you are looking for a mascara that delivers extreme volume right out of the tube.
- Don't buy if you prefer a lightweight, non-waterproof formula for everyday use.
- Don't buy if you want a mascara that offers a false lash effect without clumping.
- Don't buy if you need a product that holds curl for an extended period.
- Don't buy if you are sensitive to certain makeup ingredients and prefer hypoallergenic options.
Waterproof vs. Washable: Great Lash and Falsies
The Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara showcases the waterproof mascara benefits, designed for those who seek longevity and resistance to water, perspiration, and tears. When wearing this formula, one can expect impressive wear time as the waterproof nature allows for a smudge-free experience even during humid conditions. Additionally, this type of mascara typically strengthens its hold on lashes, promising a defined look throughout the day without flaking. Users often appreciate the thickness and lengthening effect, enhanced by the lash-doubling formula, making it a go-to choice for special occasions or outdoor activities. However, the trade-off may be in the removal process, as it often requires stronger makeup removers or oil-based cleansers.
- Offers a long-lasting hold that withstands water and sweat.
- Provides a thicker and more volumized appearance for lashes.
- May necessitate harsher removal methods.
Meanwhile, the Maybelline Volum' Express Falsies Washable Mascara highlights the washable mascara advantages, appealing to those looking for ease of use and straightforward removal. This formulation allows for effortless cleanup, making it a favorite for everyday wear. The Falsies mascara delivers a stunning volume boost while still being gentle on the lashes. Users can enjoy a luscious and full appearance without the worry of their mascara clumping or smearing under normal conditions. The trade-off with washable formulas is typically seen in their longevity; while they offer comfort, they might not withstand extreme conditions as well as their waterproof counterparts. Therefore, individuals engaging in high-activity situations or prolonged exposure to moisture may need to consider their environment when choosing this option.
- Provides ease of removal without the need for strong cleansers.
- Helps achieve a full, voluminous lash look comfortably.
- May not perform well in water or sweat-intensive situations.
Color Payoff: Very Black vs. Blackest Black
When evaluating the color intensity of Maybelline's Great Lash Waterproof Mascara in Very Black, one immediately notices a rich, deep pigmentation that aims to enhance the natural beauty of lashes. This intense black mascara is designed to provide a noticeable color impact, resulting in a versatile look that can be dressed up or maintained for a more everyday aesthetic. The Very Black formula focuses not only on pigmentation but also on volumizing and lengthening each lash. Users can expect a soft yet striking finish that offers decent opacity, creating a look that is bold but not overpowering. Ideal for those seeking a natural enhancement, it provides a reliable wear without the need for multiple coats to achieve a commanding presence.
- Rich pigmentation that enhances lash appearance.
- Suitable for day-to-night looks.
- Soft finish that maintains a natural feel.
On the other hand, Maybelline's Volum' Express Falsies Washable Mascara in Blackest Black elevates color payoff to new heights, offering an even more profound impact on lash visibility. This formulation aims to deliver the deepest, darkest shade possible, enhancing lash definition through its highly pigmented, inky black formula. The Blackest Black option is ideal for those seeking a dramatic, statement-making look. The intensity of this mascara gives lashes a fuller, more voluminous appearance while maintaining a jet-black hue that stands out beautifully in any lighting. As a result, this product serves as an excellent choice for individuals looking for the best mascara for dark lashes, ensuring that the color is vibrant and long-lasting, even under various conditions.
- Deepest pigmentation for maximum lash visibility.
- Creates a dramatic look that captivates attention.
- Formulated for voluminous and defined lashes.
Application Experience: Great Lash vs. Falsies Mascara
The Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara offers a classic wand design that is synonymous with the brand. Its brush features a tapered and traditional shape, which allows for precise application. The brush bristles are evenly spaced, making it easier to coat each lash individually. This design contributes to the easy application mascara experience, especially for those looking to achieve a more natural look. Users often find that the lengthening and volumizing formula works well for separation, reducing the risk of clumping while enhancing the lashes’ overall appearance. Its smaller size also makes it easier to navigate the inner corners of the eyes.
- Classic tapered wand design
- Evenly spaced bristles for separation
- Ideal for natural looks
In contrast, the Maybelline Volum' Express Falsies Mascara incorporates a unique spoon-shaped brush that is designed specifically for added volume and lift. This brush allows for a more dramatic effect, creating a false lash appearance. The shape helps to grip and lift each lash from the base, while its plush, dense bristles provide maximum coverage. The result is not only volumized lashes but also the ability to achieve a fluttery look with just a few strokes. For those looking for mascara application tips for fuller lashes, the Falsies mascara is particularly effective in giving a bold finish rapidly.
- Spoon-shaped brush for volume and lift
- Dense bristles for maximum coverage
- Creates a dramatic, false lash effect
The Maybelline Volum' Express Falsies Washable Mascara takes lash enhancement to the next level with its innovative design. This Blackest Black formula delivers an eye-catching volume that mimics the look of false lashes, giving your eyes that dramatic flair. Its unique spoon-shaped brush is specifically designed to lift and separate each lash, creating a fuller, more voluminous appearance without clumps. Ideal for daily wear, this mascara can be easily removed at the end of the day, making it a convenient choice for those who desire both impact and ease.
Why we picked this product for our comparison
The Maybelline Volum' Express Falsies Mascara was selected for its outstanding ability to elevate your lash game to new heights. Users rave about the impact it has on their appearance, providing a noticeable volume boost and a flirty, full lash look. Its innovative design allows for easy application, while the washable formula ensures that it is user-friendly, even for makeup novices.
We chose this product because of its versatility and the stunning results it delivers. It is perfect for those who want a bold look without the fuss of application, and its popularity reflects its effectiveness in enhancing beauty effortlessly.
- Buy if you desire a mascara that creates bold, voluminous lashes instantly.
- Buy if you prefer a washable formula that is easy to apply and remove.
- Buy if you want a deep, rich black shade that enhances eye definition.
- Buy if you enjoy a mascara that provides a fluttery, false lash effect without heavy layers.
- Buy if you appreciate a product that offers great separation of lashes without clumping.
- Don't buy if you need a waterproof mascara for long-lasting wear in humid conditions.
- Don't buy if you prefer a mascara that delivers extreme length over volume.
- Don't buy if you have very sensitive eyes and typically require hypoallergenic products.
- Don't buy if you’re looking for a high-pigment option for dramatic eye makeup.
- Don't buy if you want to avoid potential smudging or flaking during the day.
Wearing Time: Great Lash vs. Falsies Mascara
The Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara is celebrated for its impressive longevity, especially in the realm of long-lasting mascara. Users often laud its ability to remain intact throughout a busy day. When put to the test, this mascara typically stays put without major signs of flaking or smudging, making it a favorite for those looking for a mascara wear time that can endure sweat, humidity, and tears. Many consumers report that it easily survives long hours at work or during special occasions, often requiring only a gentle makeup remover at the day's end.
- Waterproof formula to prevent smudging during humid conditions.
- Users appreciate how it maintains volume and length all day.
- Some note occasional flaking after extensive wear, but it's often minor.
On the other hand, the Maybelline Volum' Express Falsies Mascara also enjoys a strong reputation for being the best mascara for all-day wear, although it is not waterproof. Users frequently share positive experiences regarding its ability to provide fuller-looking lashes without significant smudging throughout the day. However, this mascara may experience some flaking issues over extended wear, particularly in humid environments or if layered too generously. While many enjoy its easy removal compared to waterproof formulas, they sometimes seek touch-ups if they're out for an extended period.
- Washable formula offers easier removal, which some users prefer.
- Does provide an initial dramatic volume which many appreciate.
- There's more frequent mention of flaking compared to Great Lash.
You May Also Like
wet n wild High On Lash Eyelash Curler with Comfort Grip
$3.83 $3.19
Neutrogena Makeup Remover Wipes, Ultra-Soft Cleansing Facial Towelettes for Waterproof Makeup, Alcohol-Free, Plant-Based, Twin Pack, 25 Count (Pack of 2)
$16.43 $13.69
Highly Pigmented Eye Makeup Palette, Matte Shimmer Metallic Eyeshadow Pallet Long Lasting Blendable Natural Colors Make Up Eye Shadows Cosmetics Gift Kit
$11.99 $9.99
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Black 0.006 Oz
$6.00 $5.00Lash Doubling Formula: Great Lash vs. Falsies
Maybelline's Great Lash Waterproof Mascara claims to provide a unique lash-doubling formula that focuses on enhancing both the volume and length of lashes. The product features a specialized brush designed to coat each lash evenly, thereby creating a thicker, more prominent lash appearance. This mascara is marketed specifically for achieving double the lash action, lending itself to a soft yet noticeable finish that won't clump. Users often appreciate the very black hue which amplifies the overall visual impact of their lashes, making them appear fuller. Moreover, its waterproof formula ensures lasting wear throughout the day, allowing for confidence in both volume-enhancing formulas and durability.
- Designed for a soft, clump-free look.
- Features a brush made for even coating.
- Waterproof formula for long-lasting wear.
In contrast, Maybelline's Volum' Express Falsies Mascara takes a distinct approach to lash enhancement with a focus on dramatic volume and a false-lash effect. This formula is structured to wrap each lash from root to tip, creating an eye-catching lift and effective definition. Users often rave about its ability to create a bold, voluminous look, truly embodying the essence of a mascara for double lashes. The Blackest Black shade intensifies the lash visibility, delivering a captivating finish that can transform a simple makeup look into something truly striking. The flexible wand is designed to fan out lashes, preventing clumping while ensuring that each lash is beautifully separated and defined.
- Creates a bold, false-lash effect.
- Flexible wand for easy application and separation.
- Delivers a dramatic look that lasts throughout the day.
User Experience: Reviews of Great Lash vs. Falsies
When exploring the realm of mascaras, the user experiences surrounding Maybelline’s Great Lash and Falsies variations paint an interesting picture. Customers often commend the Great Lash Waterproof Mascara for its classic formula, which many describe as reliable for everyday use. One user noted, “I’ve been using Great Lash for years. It gives my lashes a natural look while still providing some volume and length.” This sentiment is echoed across mascara user reviews, highlighting the product's gentle application and its effectiveness at separating and coating each lash. However, some users wish for a bit more volume, stating, “It works great for lengthening but doesn’t give the bold, full effect I sometimes crave.” The mascara ratings reflect these mixed feelings, as it garners appreciation for its wearability yet is sometimes overshadowed by customers looking for more dramatic results.
- Natural finish praised by long-time users.
- Excellent for daily wear with comfort.
- May lack the dramatic volume some seek.
In contrast, the Falsies Volum' Express mascara tends to attract users desiring a bolder, more dramatic look. Reviews indicate that this formula is adept at delivering significant volume, with one customer stating, “Falsies gives my lashes that va-va-voom factor I love! It makes my eyes pop and holds the curl all day.” Numerous testimonials emphasize the mascara's ability to create the illusion of false lashes, lending it a strength that many users find desirable. However, some have pointed out that it can clump if not applied carefully, with one review mentioning, “I love the volume, but I need to be careful not to over-apply or it can get a bit clumpy.” This highlights the varied customer experiences mascara ratings can reflect, with the Falsies appealing more significantly to those wanting intense lash dramatization while possibly sacrificing a bit on the natural look front.
- Ideal for those seeking bold, dramatic lashes.
- Creates the illusion of false eyelashes.
- Risk of clumping if over-applied.
Related Products
Formulation Differences: Great Lash vs. Falsies
When examining the formulations of Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara and Maybelline Volum' Express Falsies Volumizing Mascara, distinct differences emerge in their ingredient compositions and the subsequent effects on lash performance. The Great Lash formula is known for its classic combination of water, waxes, and pigments, designed to provide a lightweight feel. This formulation includes ingredients like microfibers which help to lengthen lashes while maintaining a natural look. On the other hand, Falsies incorporates a unique blend of volumizing agents and fibers that deliver much more dramatic results. Its formula boasts a combination of polymers that help lift and separate lashes, creating a false-lash effect that Great Lash does not aim to replicate.
- Great Lash offers a wetter consistency that can be more forgiving, resulting in less clumping for everyday wear.
- Falsies tends to dry more quickly, allowing for a better hold of its volumizing effects.
The feel of each product on lashes is also markedly different. Great Lash tends to provide a more flexible, softer finish, whereas Falsies can feel thicker but provides more dramatic volume. With Falsies, the inclusion of ingredients like hydrolyzed silk and vitamin E contributes to a conditioning effect, making lashes feel softer even with a more substantial coating. In contrast, the Great Lash formula, while it does contain some conditioning agents, primarily focuses on achieving a smooth and clean application without the added bulk. This distinction in approach makes Great Lash more suitable for those seeking a refined, natural enhancement, while Falsies caters to those desiring bold, voluminous lashes.
- Great Lash's lightweight feel is ideal for daily use and minimal makeup looks.
- Falsies might be preferred for evening looks or special occasions due to its intense volume and dramatic finish.
Target Audience: Who Should Use Great Lash vs. Falsies?
Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara appeals to individuals seeking a classic, reliable option for their everyday makeup routine. This product is particularly suited for those with naturally fine or short lashes who desire a subtle yet noticeable enhancement. The volumizing and lengthening formula works effectively on various lash types, providing a natural look that many wearers appreciate. Great Lash is recommended for individuals who prefer easy application and removal, making it suitable for busy mornings or those new to mascara. Furthermore, this mascara can work harmoniously with different eye shapes, whether they are almond, round, or hooded, giving flexibility to users.
- Ideal for users who seek an everyday, natural look.
- Best for those with fine or short lashes.
- Perfect for individuals new to mascara.
- Suitable for different eye shapes.
On the other hand, Maybelline Volum' Express Falsies Mascara caters to users desiring a bold, dramatic effect. This product is an excellent choice for those with medium to long lashes who wish to add significant volume and a more pronounced curl. The formula is designed for individuals who love to experiment with their look, making it a great fit for special occasions, nights out, or anyone wanting to make a statement with their lashes. Falsies Mascara provides a more intense finish, making it ideal for those who enjoy a theatrical flair in their makeup. Its washable formula makes it easier to remove at the end of the day, appealing to those who prefer less fuss during the makeup removal process.
- Great for users looking for bold, dramatic lashes.
- Best for those with medium to long lashes.
- Perfect for special occasions or nights out.
- Appeals to those who prefer an easier removal process.
Our Final Recommendation
After diving into the various features and performances of both mascaras, it’s evident that while each has its own unique advantages, one stands out in the crowd. The Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara ultimately wins this comparison due to its versatility and dependable waterproof formula, making it an excellent choice for users seeking a lasting look through different conditions. Its time-tested formulation ensures lashes appear thicker, making it perfect for those who enjoy a voluminous look without the risk of smudging.
Although the Volum' Express Falsies Mascara brings excitement with its intense color payoff and ease of application, the reliability and overall lash-enhancing experience provided by Great Lash are hard to beat. Ultimately, your choice should reflect your specific needs, but for consistent results and a classic touch, Great Lash is the way to go.
