When it comes to selecting the ideal mascara, understanding the nuanced differences between popular options can significantly enhance your beauty routine. In this side-by-side comparison, we are diving deep into two prominent products from Maybelline: the Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara in Very Black and the Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara in Glam Black. Whether you're a mascara newbie or a seasoned pro, the right choice can make all the difference in achieving those coveted, luscious lashes that frame your eyes beautifully.
Our exploration will cover various aspects like formulation comparisons, brush designs, and wear times, helping you determine which mascara suits your specific needs. With the Full 'N Soft offering a soft, natural finish and the Colossal promising intense volume and waterproof durability, this guide serves to empower you with information. So, let’s unravel the secrets behind your future favorite mascara and see how these two heavyweights stack up against each other. Get ready to discover your next must-have beauty staple!
- Provides soft, defined lashes without clumping.
- Easy to wash off, suitable for those who prefer non-waterproof formulas.
- Affordable and accessible for everyday use.
- Gives a natural look, ideal for a casual makeup day.
- Contains conditioning ingredients that promote lash softness.
- May not hold a curl for very long.
- Less volumizing compared to more dramatic mascaras.
- Can smudge or flake if worn for extended periods.
- Limited water resistance; could run on rainy days.
- Requires multiple coats for the desired depth of color.
- Delivers intense volume and thickness to lashes, creating a dramatic look.
- Waterproof formula ensures long-lasting wear, perfect for humid conditions.
- Offers a bold color payoff with just a couple of swipes.
- Unique brush design separates and coats each lash evenly.
- Suitable for special occasions when you need your look to last all day.
- Can be difficult to remove without a specific eye makeup remover.
- May lead to a stiff feel on the lashes once dried.
- Could clump if too many coats are applied.
- Some users may find it too heavy for everyday wear.
- Potential irritation for sensitive eyes or contact lens wearers.
Mascara Formulation Comparison: Full 'N Soft vs Colossal
The Maybelline Full 'N Soft formulation is designed specifically to provide a soft, feathery look to the lashes while ensuring they remain pliable and comfortable throughout the day. Its unique blend is enriched with natural waxes and proteins, which work together to help maintain lash flexibility without getting clumpy. This formulation aims to create a natural appearance by enhancing the lashes without adding excessive weight, making it ideal for those who prefer a more understated look. Users often appreciate how the Full 'N Soft formula glides on smoothly during application, allowing for easy layering without risk of flaking or hardening, achieving a weightless feel. Additionally, the very black pigment offers rich color that enhances the lashes without overwhelming them.
- Natural waxes and proteins contribute to softness and flexibility.
- Intended for a more natural, feathery lash appearance.
In contrast, the Colossal Waterproof mascara ingredients focus on delivering dramatic volume and intensity. This formulation incorporates collagen to plump the lashes, creating a bold, eye-catching look. The brush is designed to capture each lash and coat it evenly with a rich amount of product, which results in a thicker and more voluminous appearance. Users often note that the Colossal mascara provides a more significant impact, suitable for those seeking a more dramatic lash statement. The waterproof aspect ensures longevity and resistance against smudging, making it a favorable option for wear in humid conditions or during emotional moments. The texture is more robust, allowing for layered applications that build volume without clumping, promoting a fierce yet defined look.
- Collagen-infused for bold volume and thickness.
- Designed for a dramatic lash impact with waterproof properties.
Brush Design Analysis: Full 'N Soft vs Colossal
The brush design of Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara is specifically tailored to deliver a soft and natural finish. Its unique brush features a full, fluffy design that enhances the volume of the lashes while maintaining a light-weight feel. This particular mascara brush is crafted to cradle each lash, ensuring even distribution of the formula without clumping. The bristles are soft and spaced out, allowing for a gentle application that separates and defines each lash, leading to a naturally enhanced look. With the ability to layer the product, users can achieve a look that feels comfortable and not overly dramatic. The size and shape of the brush are engineered to reach even the tiniest lashes, maximizing coverage and providing a lift that makes the eyes appear more awake and vibrant.
- Soft bristles for gentle application
- Fluffy design offers natural volume
- Effective separation of lashes for a defined look
In contrast, the brush design of Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara leans more towards dramatic volume and intensity. This mascara features a larger brush head that is specifically designed to load lashes with a generous amount of product. The unique, oversized bristles work together to coat each lash thoroughly, resulting in thick and full lashes that significantly enhance volume and length. The brush's design aids in delivering a bold look by concentrating the formula at the root of the lashes while fanning them out as it glides to the tips. This creates a captivatingly bold effect that can transform the eyes, giving them a more open and expressive appearance. The strategic combination of bristle length and thickness ensures that the mascara can withstand wear, making it suitable for all-day glamour.
- Larger brush head for increased product load
- Designed for maximum volume and length
- Bold effect that enhances eye expression
Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara in Very Black is a game-changer for those looking to achieve beautifully defined lashes without compromising on comfort. This mascara is specially formulated to deliver soft, fuller-looking lashes, making it perfect for everyday wear. The unique, clump-free formula allows for easy layering, giving you the flexibility to build up volume as desired. Additionally, the washable formula ensures easy removal at the end of the day, catering to those who prefer a gentle approach to their makeup routine.
Why we picked this product for our comparison
We chose Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara because of its outstanding ability to enhance lash volume while maintaining a soft, natural finish. This mascara is perfect for those who desire a lightweight feel without sacrificing definition, making it ideal for everyday use. Its washable nature appeals to individuals who prioritize ease in their beauty routine, ensuring they can swiftly remove makeup at the end of the day without fuss.
- Buy if you want soft, feathery lashes without clumping.
- Buy if you prefer a washable formula that’s easy to remove at the end of the day.
- Buy if you're looking for a mascara suitable for sensitive eyes.
- Buy if you desire everyday wear that enhances your natural look.
- Don't buy if you're in need of heavy volume or extreme length.
- Don't buy if you want a waterproof option for long wear throughout the day.
- Don't buy if you prefer mascaras with complex formulas for a dramatic effect.
- Don't buy if you're looking for a mascara that provides intense pigmentation in one swipe.
Color Options: Exploring Very Black vs Glam Black
The Very Black mascara shade offers a deep, rich black that profoundly enhances lash volume and definition. This intense hue provides an elegant and dramatic effect, making lashes appear thicker and longer. For individuals with deeper skin tones, the Very Black option is particularly striking, creating a bold contrast that accentuates the eyes. It also complements various makeup styles, whether one opts for a full glam look with bold eyeshadow or a more natural daytime appearance. The lasting impact of using Very Black lends an air of sophistication to any makeup ensemble.
- Enhances natural lash color and volume
- Perfect for dramatic eye makeup styles
- Suitable for various skin tones
On the other hand, the Glam Black mascara difference lies in its slightly less intense formula, which is designed to provide a softer, yet still impactful look that can be ideal for those seeking a more versatile appearance. The Glam Black offers a dimensional quality that maintains a dark tone without the harshness of a solid black. This can be particularly flattering for lighter skin tones or when paired with softer makeup looks, allowing for a fresh, polished appearance without overwhelming the features. The choice between Glam Black and Very Black can be influenced by personal style preferences, making it essential to consider how each variant interacts with individual skin tones.
- Offers a softer, versatile lash effect
- Ideal for lighter skin tones
- Pairs well with natural makeup styles
Application Techniques: Full 'N Soft vs Colossal
The application technique for Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara focuses on creating a natural look with soft, feathery lashes. To achieve optimal results, start by ensuring that your lashes are clean and dry. Using the Full 'N Soft wand, which features a flexible brush, gently wiggle the brush at the base of your lashes and then sweep it upward. This method allows for even distribution of the formula while preventing clumps. It's beneficial to apply a second coat if you desire more definition; however, allow the first layer to dry slightly to maintain a light feel. Applying the mascara in a zigzag motion not only helps to separate lashes but also enhances the soft effect that this mascara promotes. For the best results, focus on the tips of your lashes during the final sweep, as this technique creates an elongated appearance.
- Ensure lashes are clean and dry before application.
- Wiggle the brush at the lash base for an even distribution.
- Apply additional coats after slight drying for a more defined look.
- Utilize a zigzag motion to separate and enhance softness.
- Focus on tips for elongation during the final sweep.
On the other hand, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara employs a different approach, aimed at delivering dramatic volume and intensity. Begin by lifting the wand and ensuring you have a generous amount of product on the brush, which is designed with a thick, oversized bristle layout. Start at the root of your lashes and pull upwards in a steady motion, applying pressure to compress the lashes against the brush for maximum volume. This mascara formula allows for layering without looking heavy, so multiple coats can be applied while the previous layers remain wet. To achieve an extra boost, consider using a side-to-side swirling motion while moving up, which will help plump up the lashes and create a captivating fan effect. This technique pairs perfectly with bold make-up looks, allowing for a more glamorous finish.
- Use a thick, oversized brush for dramatic volume.
- Apply pressure during the upward motion for enhanced fullness.
- Layer while wet for a multi-dimensional effect.
- Incorporate side-to-side swirling for even more puffiness.
- Ideal for pairing with bold make-up looks for a glamorous finish.
Mascara Wear Time: Comparing Full 'N Soft and Colossal
The wear time of Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara is tailored for those seeking a natural look combined with comfort. Its formula experiences varying degrees of performance influenced by environmental conditions such as humidity and sweat. When exposed to humidity, this mascara tends to maintain its soft finish and does not clump, which is vital for everyday wear. For individuals engaging in daily activities that may induce perspiration, Full 'N Soft generally offers a satisfactory level of durability, although it may require occasional touch-ups to prevent smudging. The mascara's washable nature allows for easy removal, making it particularly appealing for those who prefer gentle cleaning methods. However, a rigorous workout or a day at the beach might challenge its longevity, as the product is not waterproof and tends to wear off with excess moisture.
- Designed for daily wear
- Offers a soft and natural look
- Water-resistant but not waterproof
- Enhances comfort with lightweight feel
In contrast, Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara emphasizes a robust formulation aimed at all-day wear under varying conditions, particularly favorable for individuals who need something more resilient. The waterproof mascara longevity ensures that it holds up exceptionally well against perspiration, humidity, and other moisture sources. This mascara's thicker formula can cling to lashes, providing substantial volume without clumping while resisting the effects of sweat or splash. As a result, the Colossal waterproof option tends to stay significantly intact, making it suitable for high-energy days or events where durability is essential. While the mascara is designed to withstand moisture, it is still important for users to utilize effective makeup removers after a long day, to ensure complete removal without irritating the delicate eye area.
- Long-lasting and volumizing
- Holds up against humidity and sweat
- Ideal for high-energy activities
- Requires effective makeup removal methods
Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara in Glam Black is the ultimate choice for creating dramatic, eye-catching lashes that stand the test of time. This volumizing mascara boasts a unique collagen-infused formula that provides incredible volume and definition, perfect for making a bold statement. Designed to be waterproof, it resists smudging and flaking, ensuring your look stays intact from morning to night. Its oversized brush effortlessly coats each lash, giving you an impactful, wide-eyed appearance that lasts.
Why we picked this product for our comparison
Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara was selected for its remarkable performance in delivering dramatic volume and long-lasting wear. We appreciate its waterproof formula, catering to those who need a reliable option for all-day events or activities, whether it's a day at the beach or a night out. The impressive brush design allows for effortless application, making this mascara a top choice for anyone looking to make their eyes pop.
- Buy if you want bold, volumized lashes that make a statement.
- Buy if you're looking for a mascara that withstands water and sweat.
- Buy if you enjoy a rich, long-lasting color that enhances your eye makeup.
- Buy if you're all about that dramatic look that turns heads.
- Don't buy if you prefer a natural look with softer lash definition.
- Don't buy if you're sensitive to waterproof formulas that can be harder to remove.
- Don't buy if you want a quick-to-apply mascara for casual use.
- Don't buy if clumping is a concern; this mascara can build up quickly if applied excessively.
Removing Mascara: Full 'N Soft vs Colossal
When discussing the process of removing mascara, it’s essential to highlight the differences between Maybelline's Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara and the Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara. The Full 'N Soft formula is designed for easy removal, making it a favorite for those who prefer a gentle approach. To effectively remove this washable mascara, makeup removers with water-based formulations often yield the best results. Gentle cleansers or micellar water can be used with a cotton pad; this technique not only helps in breaking down the product effortlessly but also leaves the lashes feeling soft and cared for. It is recommended to soak the cotton pad with the remover and hold it against the lashes for a few seconds before wiping it away, ensuring that the mascara dissolves fully without harsh rubbing.
- Water-based cleansers work effectively for Full 'N Soft.
- Gentle techniques prevent lash damage during removal.
Conversely, the Colossal Waterproof Mascara requires a different method due to its waterproof formulation, which tends to adhere more strongly to the lashes. Here, an oil-based makeup remover is generally advised—a product specifically designed for waterproof makeup will enhance the effectiveness of the removal process. To properly remove Colossal mascara, users can apply the oil-based remover with a cotton pad, allowing it to sit for a moment to break down the formula before wiping. This technique reduces the risk of leftover mascara and maintains the integrity of the lashes, even under the more formidable grip of a waterproof formula.
- Oil-based removers are ideal for Colossal mascara removal.
- Allowing the remover to sit can enhance the effectiveness.
You May Also Like
wet n wild High On Lash Eyelash Curler with Comfort Grip
$3.83 $3.19
Neutrogena Makeup Remover Wipes, Ultra-Soft Cleansing Facial Towelettes for Waterproof Makeup, Alcohol-Free, Plant-Based, Twin Pack, 25 Count (Pack of 2)
$16.43 $13.69
Highly Pigmented Eye Makeup Palette, Matte Shimmer Metallic Eyeshadow Pallet Long Lasting Blendable Natural Colors Make Up Eye Shadows Cosmetics Gift Kit
$11.99 $9.99
e.l.f. No Budge Retractable Eyeliner, Creamy, Ultra-Pigmented & Waterproof, Creates Bold & Defined Lines, Vegan & Cruelty-Free, Black 0.006 Oz
$6.00 $5.00Target Audience: Who Should Choose Full 'N Soft vs Colossal?
Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara is ideal for makeup wearers who prioritize a natural look in their daily routine. Its formulation is highly suitable for individuals who prefer lightweight coverage, offering a soft, defined lash effect without the dramatic clumpiness that can accompany more volumizing products. This mascara appeals to those who are looking for the best mascara for daily wear, especially for individuals with sensitive eyes or contact lenses. Typically, the target audience includes busy professionals and students who desire a polished yet effortless appearance. The ease of removal also makes it appealing to individuals who prefer a hassle-free evening routine.
- Ideal for natural makeup lovers
- Perfect for daily activities and casual outings
- Best suited for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
On the other hand, Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara caters to a completely different demographic—those looking for high impact and long-lasting performance. This mascara is tailored for individuals who enjoy bold makeup and may engage in activities where eye makeup could be compromised, such as sports or events involving emotion (like weddings or concerts). The volumizing formula serves the needs of makeup enthusiasts who favor a dramatic lash look, making it more appealing to individuals who often engage in glamorous occasions or photography. The waterproof aspect ensures that it can withstand sweat and tears, making it suitable for frequent use, particularly in humid or active environments.
- Great for dramatic and special occasions
- Perfect for makeup enthusiasts and those with active lifestyles
- Ideal for individuals looking for a long-lasting, volumizing effect
Mascara Performance in Various Conditions: A Real-World Look
The Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara has garnered attention for its ability to provide a soft, natural look while still delivering impressive longevity. Users have shared experiences of wearing this mascara in humid environments, noting that while some moisture can challenge the formula, it largely stands the test, with only minor smudging reported during a summer outing at a beach festival. A tester mentioned how she felt comfortable with a light application, as this product allowed her lashes to remain defined without the heaviness that often comes with waterproof options. The formula appears to adapt well to the skin's condition throughout the day, and many have found it easy to remove, which is particularly beneficial for those who prefer gentler makeup solutions at the end of the day.
- Maintains a natural look even after several hours of wear.
- Generally holds well in moderately humid settings.
- Easy to remove, ideal for daily use, especially in dry climates.
In contrast, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara excels in more extreme conditions, especially when it comes to humidity resistance. Real-world mascara tests reveal that this waterproof formula holds up admirably during intense activities, truly shining during a rainy outdoor concert where users reported minimal flaking or smudging. One enthusiastic user recounted her experience skiing in snowy weather, noting how her lashes stayed fully voluminous without any signs of wear, a testament to its robust waterproof capabilities. Many have found this mascara particularly advantageous for long days filled with adventure or when the weather doesn’t cooperate, making it a go-to choice whenever durability is non-negotiable.
- Exceptional hold in humid and wet conditions.
- Retains volume and definition despite heavy physical activity.
- Often recommended for occasions requiring a strong all-day wear.
Related Products
Environmental Considerations: Washable vs Waterproof Mascaras
The environmental impact of mascara varies significantly between washable mascara and waterproof mascara, particularly in terms of ingredients, production processes, and disposal considerations. The Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara, crafted for easy removal, typically employs water-soluble polymers that align with sustainable mascara choices. These compounds are less likely to cause harm to aquatic ecosystems upon washing off, as they dissolve easily and can be rinsed away without leaving behind microplastics. In terms of production, washable mascaras often require less energy and fewer resources, given that they do not need to incorporate intensive chemical formulations to achieve their effects.
- Ingredients are often simpler, leading to a potentially lower carbon footprint.
- They support simpler disposal, reducing the risk of environmental contamination.
In contrast, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara relies on more complex formulations that provide long-lasting wear through oil-based ingredients and waxes. This content contributes to a more significant environmental impact of mascara, particularly concerning the breakdown of these materials in water systems. Waterproof mascaras often necessitate stronger, synthetic emulsifiers due to their resistance to moisture, which can lead to microplastics entering the ocean during production and disposal. Furthermore, the production of waterproof formulas usually involves more intricate processes that require higher energy use and resource extraction.
- Sophisticated chemical formulations can complicate biodegradable breakdown.
- Disposal methods may also be impacted, as stronger removers are often needed, increasing environmental footprint.
Lash Care: How Each Mascara Affects Lash Health
The ingredients in Maybelline New York Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara play a crucial role in determining how this product affects mascara and lash health over time. Formulated with a blend of soft, flexible fibers, this mascara aims to enhance the natural look of lashes by providing volume without sacrificing softness. The inclusion of moisturizing agents in its formula ensures that lashes do not feel brittle or stiff, which can be a common issue with some mascaras. This nurturing approach can potentially support lash strength, leading to healthier-looking lashes as it reduces the risk of breakage. Additionally, the washable formula makes it easier to remove product at the end of the day, limiting the potential for lash damage associated with harsher, waterproof removers.
- Soft, flexible fibers promote a natural look while supporting lash health.
- Moisturizing agents help prevent brittleness and breakage.
- Washable formula minimizes damage during removal.
On the other hand, Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara incorporates a different set of ingredients designed for a more dramatic impact on lash fullness, focusing on significant volume while maintaining the integrity of lashes. The waterproof formulation ensures that it adheres firmly to the lashes throughout the day, offering longevity and resistance to smudging—important for those who want a bold look. However, the long-wear nature of this mascara can pose challenges for lash health if not adequately removed. Ingredients that enhance adherence can sometimes lead to weakening the lashes over prolonged use. If removal is rushed or ineffective, it might result in increased lash loss or damage. Therefore, while this mascara excels in delivering dramatic volume, it is essential for users to be diligent in their removal process to maintain lash health.
- Formulated for dramatic volume and long-lasting wear.
- Waterproof capabilities ensure smudge resistance.
- Potential for lash weakening if not removed properly.
Our Final Recommendation
After meticulously analyzing the Full 'N Soft Washable Mascara and the Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara, it’s clear that each has its unique benefits and ideal use cases. However, if we had to pinpoint a winner in this mascara showdown, the Maybelline Volum' Express Colossal Waterproof Mascara takes the crown. Its ability to provide unparalleled volume while resisting the elements makes it an excellent choice for long days or special occasions.
Ultimately, the decision on which mascara to choose boils down to your personal preference and lifestyle. If you're seeking all-day durability and a dramatic look, the Colossal's characteristics will serve you better. Meanwhile, if you prefer a softer finish for your everyday look, the Full 'N Soft might be the way to go. Regardless of your choice, both mascaras promise to elevate your lash game, so embrace the glamour that each offers!
